Maximising Loyalty: How to Build a Branded Rewards Program on Shopify

Turning one-time shoppers into regulars – and regulars into proper raving fans – is one of the most reliable ways to grow a Shopify store. A solid loyalty programme gives people a real reason to come back, spend a bit more, and tell others about you. When it’s done well, it’s more than just another marketing trick; it becomes the backbone of genuine customer relationships that grow stronger month after month.

Why Loyalty Matters on Shopify

For most Shopify merchants, the biggest wins don’t come from more traffic – they come from getting existing customers to buy again. A strong loyalty program:

• increases customer lifetime value
• smooths out seasonal dips
• creates more chances to engage beyond sales and discounts

Because Shopify brings your products, orders, and customer accounts together in one place, it’s a natural home for a rewards strategy. Whether you sell online, in-store with Shopify POS, or both, you can start small, measure results, and scale as you grow.

How Shopify Loyalty Programs Usually Work

Most Shopify loyalty setups use one or more of these models:

Points

Customers earn points for actions like placing an order, creating an account, leaving a review, or following your social channels. They can redeem those points for discounts, free gifts, or shipping perks.

Tiers / VIP Levels

Shoppers unlock higher tiers (e.g., Bronze, Silver, Gold) based on spend or activity. Higher levels come with better perks such as exclusive discounts, early access, or birthday rewards.

Referrals

Existing customers earn rewards for referring friends who make their first purchase – often paired with a welcome offer for the new customer.

A simple example might be: 5 points per £1 spent, £5 off at 500 points, VIP customers get an extra 10% off, and a “give £5, get £5” referral link included in post-purchase emails. The key is simplicity – customers should instantly understand the value.

Recommended Shopify Loyalty Apps

Shopify’s app ecosystem makes it easy to plug in a full loyalty engine without development work. Three consistently strong options are:

Smile: Loyalty & Rewards

One of the most popular choices. Offers points, VIP tiers, referrals, a branded loyalty page, and integrations with Klaviyo, Judge.me, and Gorgias.

Best for: Small to mid-sized merchants wanting a quick, friendly setup.

LoyaltyLion

A mature, data-driven loyalty platform with points, referrals, VIP tiers, dedicated loyalty pages, and detailed analytics.

Best for: Brands focused on long-term retention strategies.

Yotpo Loyalty & Rewards

Pairs loyalty with reviews and UGC, letting you reward customers for creating content as well as making purchases.

Best for: Stores already using or planning to use Yotpo’s reviews, SMS, or email tools.

There are hundreds of other apps, but these have long track records, deep Shopify integrations, and enough flexibility for both small businesses and high-growth brands.

Quick Feature Comparison

Making Your Program Feel On-Brand

The difference between a generic points scheme and a genuinely branded loyalty program is all in the execution.

Name It Well

Choose a name that fits your brand personality, but isn’t confusing. For example, a Belfast coffee roaster might call theirs Brew Crew to foster a sense of personality and connection, while the likes of Starbucks has named their own Starbucks Rewards – letting the brand name speak for itself, and keeping things simple. 

Own the Look and Feel

Match your colours, typography, and tone across widgets, emails, and landing pages so customers stay immersed in your brand world. 

Offer Rewards They Actually Want

Sometimes a 5% discount is less compelling than early access to a new collection, a limited-run bundle, or an invite to a local event. Build perks around what excites your audience.

On Shopify, you can show loyalty balances in the customer account area, add point-earning nudges on product pages (“Buy this and earn 120 points”), and trigger automated emails when someone is close to a reward – all without feeling pushy.

Using Loyalty Data in Email Flows

This is where many loyalty programs really start to pay off. By connecting your loyalty app to your email platform, you can:

• trigger emails when a customer is close to a reward threshold
• personalise campaigns based on points balance or VIP tier
• reward repeat customers automatically after their second or third order
• include referral links directly in post-purchase and win-back flows

Instead of relying on one-off broadcasts, loyalty becomes part of your always-on retention engine – reinforcing value every time a customer hears from you.

Practical Steps to Get Started

For most small businesses, the best approach is to launch something simple, gather data, and refine.

1. Set one clear goal: More repeat orders? Higher average order value? More reviews?
2. Choose one app and configure basic earning rules – points per pound spent, bonus points for account creation, and rewards for reviews.
3. Create a dedicated loyalty page on your Shopify store explaining how it works, and link to it from your navigation, footer, and post-purchase emails.
4. Measure over a few months: Look at repeat purchase rate, average order value, engagement with loyalty emails, and redemption activity.

If you also sell in-store via Shopify POS, choose an app that supports unified points so customers earn and redeem seamlessly wherever they shop.

Ready to Talk About Loyalty?

A thoughtful loyalty program can turn one-off orders into dependable repeat customers – the foundation of any sustainable Shopify business. If you’d like help choosing the right app or designing a program that fits your brand, feel free to get in touch.

If you are on the hunt for more Shopify advice, you can always sign up to our newsletter, too.